In his first public comments in 10 days, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell spoke for 45 minutes. To say the reactions were mixed would be a grave understatement.
He announced a personal conduct committee that will be in place by the Super Bowl to look at improving the personal conduct policy. Goodell acknowledged failures by himself and the league.
“Unfortunately over the past several weeks we have seen all too much of the NFL doing wrong. That starts with me,” said Goodell.
He also stated that “he got it wrong” on the Ray Rice case on “a number of levels”, and that the league “will get our house in order”. In terms of changing the personal conduct policy, Goodell said that he and NFLPA Executive Director DeMaurice Smith have talked about potential changes to the personal conduct policy, and will meet together starting next week, will both of them planning to meet outside experts to give ideas and insight. The phrase “everything is on the table” was repeated several times in terms of Goodell potentially having less power in conduct policy and enforcement.
However, Goodell was not specific on certain topics and questions. When asked about what Ray Rice told him about the elevator incident, Goodell said Rice’s account was “inconsistent” with what was seen on the second video tape released by TMZ.
TMZ told Goodell at the press conference that they were able to get the second video tape with one phone call, while Goodell said that according to the league’s security department, there were attempts to get the video tape that ended in June.
The independent investigation by former FBI Director Robert Mueller has come under fire because of Mueller’s law firm, Wilmerhale, helped the league negotiate a multi-billion dollar contract extension with DirecTV. When asked about the appearance of impropriety, Goodell was stern in his belief that the investigation will be truly independent.
“You are now questioning the integrity of the (former) director of the FBI,” said Goodell.
Partnerships with the National Domestic Violence Hotline and National Sexual Violence Resource Center were announced by Goodell. He also said NFL teams and league staff will have education sessions starting in the next month, and then training programs that are being “developed by a top group of experts”.
On the Adrian Peterson alleged child abuse case, Goodell said “what we see so far is tragic”, but stressed that he wanted the facts of the case to come out.
The commissioner said that he has not considered resigning despite calls for him to resign. But during and after the press conference, current and former NFL players were critical of Goodell:
This press conference is pointless
— Darius Butler (@DariusJButler) September 19, 2014
Boo this man…
I know some people that got it wrong and don't have a job anymore. Does this mean it's ok to get it wrong? You gain 0 yards on an inc pass!
— Sidney Rice (@sidneyrice) September 19, 2014
A lot of " We got it wrong, We didn't do this or that " if your the judge and the juror it's " I" the best ability is Accountability
— Beanie Wells (@BeanieWells26) September 19, 2014
He looks upset because he's unprepared
— Beanie Wells (@BeanieWells26) September 19, 2014
Don't think anyone would want to be under the spotlight that @nfl & @nflcommish are under at this very moment
— Kevin Mawae (@KevinMawae) September 19, 2014
Can any person ever have any more ambiguous answers than the @nflcommish did today?
— Kevin Mawae (@KevinMawae) September 19, 2014
Mark Schlereth on Goodell: "You have one of the most important performances of your career and you showed up 17 mins late. Unacceptable."
— NFL on ESPN (@ESPNNFL) September 19, 2014
Tedy Bruschi on NFL Live: "I want a new commissioner to lead my league…Roger Goodell needs to step down."
— NFL on ESPN (@ESPNNFL) September 19, 2014
Mark Schlereth: "The majority of players that play in this league right now & former players do not trust the commissioner of this league."
— NFL on ESPN (@ESPNNFL) September 19, 2014
Tedy Bruschi on NFL Live: "We needed someone to go up there and be a leader…and that wasn't done." pic.twitter.com/9PuP1bQuQc
— NFL on ESPN (@ESPNNFL) September 19, 2014
Bruschi: "If someone else made (his mistakes), there would've been repercussions. But there's nothing for Goodell." pic.twitter.com/BPGmRiskUb
— NFL on ESPN (@ESPNNFL) September 19, 2014
How the personal conduct policy and league programs will be implemented and received by players remains to be seen, but immediate reaction is very negative.
Update 6:12 p.m.:
Terry O’Neil, the President of the National Organization for Women (NOW) and a staunch critic of Goodell who previously asked for his resignation, released a statement on today’s press conference:
NFL Commissioner, Roger Goodell, today did nothing to increase confidence in his ability to lead the NFL out of its morass. Of course, it is fine to provide funding to the National Domestic Violence Hotline and the National Sexual Violence Resource Center. But like Mr. Goodell’s other announcements, it is aimed at moving this story off the front page. What Mr. Goodell doesn’t seem to understand is that he should be aiming to make fundamental changes in the organization.
Glaringly absent from Mr. Goodell’s remarks is a commitment to conduct an independent investigation into all of the incidents of domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault and stalking on his watch. Such an investigation would, at minimum, ask how many victims reached out to NFL leadership for help over the years? What was the response? What services did the victims request? Did they receive them? If not, why not? Were the victims satisfied? What steps does the NFL take, as part of its response protocol, to keep the victims safe? What are its metrics of success — how does it measure whether the victim is safe? What about the victim’s economic security? What measures does the NFL take to ensure the victim’s economic security?
Roger Goodell’s steadfast refusal to broach these questions speaks a lot louder than his formulaic mea culpas and repeated promises that he’s going to do better. NOW continues to demand that he resign and that his successor appoint a thorough, independent investigator with full authority to unpack all relevant aspects of the NFL’s response to incidents of domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault and stalking, and to make serious recommendations for change.
The time for half measures and PR feints is long past. For the good of the NFL, Roger Goodell must go.
More stories you might like